Apology
399 BCE
"The unexamined life is not worth living."
Socrates, at age 70, stands trial before the Athenian court on charges of impiety and corrupting the youth. Rather than beg for mercy, he delivers a defense that has echoed through Western civilization—a vindication of the philosophical life and a challenge to all who would silence inquiry.
The Charges
Socrates addresses the jury of 501 Athenian citizens. He faces two sets of accusers: the old prejudices spread over many years—that he is a natural philosopher who studies things in the heavens and below the earth, and makes the weaker argument defeat the stronger—and the formal charges brought by Meletus: that he corrupts the young and does not believe in the gods of the city.
He begins by warning the jury not to expect the eloquent rhetoric they are accustomed to. He will speak plainly, as he always has, in the marketplace and the gymnasium. At seventy years old, this is his first time in a law court. He asks only that they judge him by the truth of his words, not the manner of their delivery.
The Oracle at Delphi
Socrates explains how his mission began. His friend Chaerephon once asked the Oracle at Delphi whether anyone was wiser than Socrates. The Oracle replied that no one was wiser. This puzzled Socrates, who knew he possessed no special wisdom.
"I am wiser than this man; for neither of us really knows anything fine and good, but this man thinks he knows something when he does not, whereas I, as I do not know anything, do not think I do either."
To test the Oracle, Socrates questioned those reputed to be wise—politicians, poets, craftsmen. Each time he found that they believed themselves wise but could not give a coherent account of the knowledge they claimed. Socrates concluded that his wisdom consisted only in knowing that he did not know.
The Examined Life
This questioning made Socrates many enemies among the powerful, but he could not stop. He understood his mission as a divine command—to examine himself and others, to show that the pursuit of wisdom matters more than wealth, reputation, or honor.
"The unexamined life is not worth living for a human being."
He compares himself to a gadfly stinging a great and noble horse that has grown sluggish. Athens, blessed with advantages, has become complacent. Socrates' role is to rouse the city from its stupor, to remind citizens that care of the soul is more important than care of the body or possessions.
Cross-Examining Meletus
Socrates turns his method upon his accuser Meletus. Through pointed questions, he exposes the incoherence of the charges. Meletus claims Socrates corrupts the youth—but who improves them? Everyone else, apparently. This is absurd: in every other domain, the many corrupt and only the expert improves.
On the charge of atheism, Socrates catches Meletus in contradiction. The indictment says Socrates introduces new divinities, yet also that he believes in no gods at all. These cannot both be true. Meletus has not thought carefully about his accusations—he has brought them out of spite, not conviction.
The Fear of Death
Some might ask: could Socrates not simply stop philosophizing and save his life? He cannot. To fear death is to claim knowledge one does not have—for no one knows whether death is the greatest of blessings. What Socrates does know is that to disobey a superior, divine or human, is evil and disgraceful.
"To fear death is nothing other than to think oneself wise when one is not; for it is to think one knows what one does not know."
Even if the jury offered to acquit him on condition that he cease philosophizing, he would refuse. He must obey the god rather than them. He will continue, as long as he breathes, to exhort everyone he meets to care first for wisdom and truth, and only secondarily for wealth and reputation.
The Verdict
The jury votes: 280 guilty, 221 not guilty. Socrates notes that if only thirty votes had gone the other way, he would have been acquitted. The margin is narrower than he expected, given the prejudice against him.
Meletus proposes death. Socrates must propose a counter-penalty. What does he deserve for spending his life urging Athenians to care for virtue? Free meals in the Prytaneum, he suggests—the honor given to Olympic victors. But the jury is not amused.
He refuses exile—he would only continue philosophizing elsewhere and be driven out again. He refuses to weep and bring his children before the court to beg for mercy. This would be shameful, unworthy of his reputation, and an attempt to corrupt the jury's judgment through emotion rather than reason.
To Those Who Condemned Him
The jury votes for death. Socrates addresses those who condemned him: they have gained little time by killing him, for he is old and would have died soon anyway. But the disgrace will follow them. Other examiners will arise, younger and harsher than Socrates. Silencing critics does not lead to virtue—only self-examination can.
"It is not difficult to avoid death; it is much more difficult to avoid wickedness, for it runs faster than death."
To Those Who Voted for Acquittal
To those who voted to acquit, Socrates offers consolation. His divine sign, which always stops him when he is about to do wrong, has not opposed him today. This suggests that what has happened is good. Death is either a dreamless sleep—nothing to fear—or a journey to another place where he can converse with Homer, Hesiod, and all the heroes of old.
"No evil can happen to a good man, either in life or after death."
"The hour of departure has arrived, and we go our separate ways—I to die, and you to live. Which of these two is better only the god knows."
— Socrates
End of Text
Translation based on Benjamin Jowett's rendering, with adaptations for clarity.
Return to Library